7 Jul
2011
7 Jul
'11
3:58 p.m.
June Meeting Minutes
2011-06-28
19:05 UTC
Fezile IRC Server, #meeting
Participants
=============
- Jan_Blomqvist_Kinander
- Igor_Paliychuk
- MfldElton
- Usurp
- Aleksey_Bragin
- Thomas_Faber
- Giannis_Adamopoulos
- Thomas_Faber
- Johannes_Anderwald
- Timo_Kreuzer
- Olaf_Siejka
- Jerome_Gardou
- Gabriel_Ilardi
- Andrew_Green
- Javier_Fernandez
- Victor_Martinez
- Amine_Khaldi
- Claudiu_Mihail
- Colin_Finck
- Rafal_Harabien
- Sylvain_Petreolle
- Matthias_Kupfer
- Danny_Goette
- Maciej_Bialas
- Ged_Murphy
- Ziliang_Guo
- Art_Yerkes
- Cameron_Gutman
- Neeraj_Yadav
- Herve_Poussineau
- Daniel_Reimer
- James_Tabor
- Olaf_Siejka
- Samuel_Serapion
- Pierre_Schweitzer
- Alex_Ionescu
- Gabriel_Ilardi
Proceedings
============
○ Meeting called to order at 19:05 UTC by Aleksey Bragin.
○ ReactOS Project coordinator Aleksey Bragin listed the points of the proposed agenda for
June meeting:
1. Cmake switching
2. Next ReactOS release
3. Website revamp status
4. GSoC status
5. Developers status reports
The Minute Taker rol was given to Victor_Martinez for this meeting.
○ Point 1: CMake switching
--------------------------------------------
■ The ReactOS developer Timo gave a quick sum up about CMake status:
He reported that the CMake build is more or less ready, currently missing rosapps. He
stated that rosapps are not a major problem as they're rarely used, and cmake files
for them can be done if needed.
He also mentioned a problem, confirmed by Igor_Paliychuk, related to booting in real
hardware, in addition to the winmm:mci regression.
The problem detected in real hardware is very specific to the hardware combination thus
hard to test.
■ Amine mentioned that several comparative tests have been done through buildbot/testman
between the rbuild build and the CMake build, showing no measurable differences. He also
stated that the CMake port shouldn't be considered done yet, as it still lacks many
planned features.
He highlighted some of the CMake patches,made by Jerome, to be sent upstream, like the PCH
support and its related dependency tracking, and also the benefits of using CMake to
compile ros, like the improved performance, the small disk space needed for builds (half
of what the rbuild builds require) and the cool new kdbg features.Gabriel_Ilardi expressed
his concers about merging more code in the current trunk situation. Timo replied that no
code merge is needed,in case of switching to Cmake.
■ Timo, Colin and Aleksey asked about measuring the CMake build performance over the
rbuild build in numbers. Jerome performed a quick benchmark:
First test: makex ntoskrnl (all clean, toold already built). Cmake: 04:06 , Rbuild: 04:55
(17% faster)
Second test: rebuild (only dependencies check). Cmake: 0:28 , Rbuild: 1:04 (56% faster)
The benchmark shows Cmake is faster not only for a full compilation but also recompiling
(ntoskrnl) modules.
■ The ReactOS Cmake Team suggested to begin using Cmake with current RosBE to compile
ReactOS ISOs in order to assure they are as good as Rbuild’s.
A "How to compile with Cmake" tutorial can be found in the following wikipage:
http://reactos.org/wiki/Cmake
Summing up, the Cmake switch will bring better dependency checking, fast rebuild of single
modules and much better symbols support in kdbg according to the ReactOS Cmake Team
The technical description was left to be discussed in #reactos-dev, if anyone was
interested.
○ Point 2 : Next ReactOS release
--------------------------------------------------------
¦ReactOS release was the 2nd point of the June meeting agenda.
■ Gabriel_Ilardi and Victor_Martinez were asked to report current trunk state from
Compatibility/Stability point of view.
Accordingly to forum threads, Bugzilla new entries, and Own testing,Gabriel and Victor
said important regressions have been introduced due the latest changes, and mainly the LDR
rewrite.
Wrong icons, impossibility to shutdown, AC97 hang, several installers/apps failing are
some of those important regressions.
■ Art_Yerkes has been giving a look at the AC97 bug, he was able to gather a lot of
information about the regression and asks for collaboration to fix it.
■ Aleksey_Bragin, as the author of the LDR rewrite, stated that he knew the new LDR could
introduce regressions but that it is a big step forward.
The top priority is fixing those LDR regressions, instead of reverting, as the old LDR was
indeed worse.
Aleksey remarks that he needs every dev to take a look at the LDR bugs and try to fix
them.
The LDR regressions should be really easy to fix thanks to the rewrite, he said.
■ Amine_Khaldi suggested to decide when it is time to release performing bugfixing and
full regression testing.
■ The idea of performing full regression tests now was inmediatly rejected by Colin_Finck
and Olaf_Siejka since bug reports are currently showing that our trunk is in a really bad
shape. Due to this, the Release discussion will be on hold until the next meeting.
During this month ReactOS devs are suggested to focus in bugfixing mainly the LDR code.
As these bugs are critical and able to hide other minors regressions, a special call is
being made:
****************Special Call****************
"Please pick a bug from the linked ones in
http://reactos.org/bugzilla/show_bug.cgi?id=6346 "
****************Special Call****************
○ Point 3 : Website Revamp Status
-------------------------------------------------------
¦ Thanks to Colin's help, a new playground with correct permissions and tied to an SVN
branch has been created.
■ Niski and aross, main webrevamp developers, have been focused on Bugzilla and Mediawiki
integration, compatdb drupal port, and forum.
Forum will have new features as "the best answer" and "karma" modules
which will improve forum users experience.
■ Niski has completed the work on Bugzilla and Mediawiki while aross is working on
compatdb and the new forum.
■ Right now, Amine said, a design/layout work is needed in parallel.
■ Colin_Finck stated that finding a designer among ReactOS developers is more difficult
than findind a developer so he offered himself to help with the design/layout.
○ Point 4: Gsoc status
-------------------------------------------------------------------
■ AndrewGreen is currently cleaning a mixture of explorer_new, atl com and browseui
code. The resultant code will be commited afterwards.
Although he recognizes his project is behind schedule, after apologizing he says he’s
confident to meet the goals by midsemester evaluation.
Ged_Murphy cpp shell32 code will allow him to use atl com for everything shell related.
Colin_Finck and Olaf_Siejka discussed the best way to test the new implementation to check
for any possible regressions, due to the fact that Ged was not around the discussion was
postponed.
Jerome_Gardou asked Andrew about the WINE Shell32 Gsoc project but accordingly to Olaf,
Wine has refused to cooperate regarding those.
Status: Behind Schedule.
■ Giannis_Adamopoulos was too busy with exams so his project was parked a little. His
commits will raise up when the last exam is done.
Status: On time
■ Claudiu_Mihail thanked the great help of Cameron_Gutman and Art_Yerkes. The project is
set to meet the deadlines for midterm.
There are still two problems remaining: browsers don't work(it will be solved by
midterms), slowness of the lwIP implementation.
He has followed the test approach using several simple test apps and fixing revealed
bugs.
After finishing his thesis project, which is highly related to his Gsoc project,he will
start commiting again.
■ Neeraj_Yadav has divided his sound project in 5 parts.
1.[Finished] Writing a skeleton server which can hold the audio converter modules and the
mixer modules ...This server should be capable of insertion in the reactos audio chain [4
weeks]
2.[Now] Writing mixer modules [2 weeks]
3.Writing audio converter [ 4 weeks]
4.Inserting this audio server in the reactos audio chain [1 week]
5.testing/styling/documentation [1 week]
He expects to finish the 2nd step in midterm evaluation.
Alex_Ionescu and Giannis_Adamopoulos asked for a way to test Neeraj code.
If anyone is interested, this is the best way:
1)make audsrv && make audclient
2)run audsrv -n in one console
3)run audclient in other
4)open as many audclients as you want
5)the server should play a mixed sound
Status: On time
■ Thomas_Faber is finishing the main framework needed to run the tests. Most of the old
tests have been ported and now he is currently working on getting special-purpose drivers
and usermode test parts up and running.
Lately he has been quite busy with a university project but he expects to commit the
framework in these days.
Status: On time
■ Timo_Kreuzer has finished the font driver loading and now he is working on the font
mapper, which is complex and needs a good design.
Status: Ahead of time
○ Point 5: Developers status reports
-------------------------------------------------------------------
■ Alex_Ionescu will help Aleksey commit his scater/gather DMA patch.
■ Alex_Bragin is working on remaining LDR code and afterwards he'll take part in
processing bugzilla patches.
■ Amine_Khaldi is focused in cmake and the website revamp.
■ Art_Yerkes made some improvements to symbol handling in the cmake branch and now he’s
working with Claudiu.
■ Colin_Finck has been trying the KDUSBCOM idea (KD DLL for debugging over an
USB-to-Serial adapter), and he’s moving now to help with the website layout.
■ Daniel_Reimer is playing with Gcc builds and updating RosBE.He added Cmake support a
while ago and he is still battling with GCC 4.6 and Wine RC files.
■ Gabriel_Ilardi is focused in mantaining Bugzilla and the forum and he’s performing some
testing in his few spare time.
■ Ged_Murphy is helping with shell32 c++ fixup
■ Herve_Poussineau is currently inactive on ReactOS
■ James_Tabor is still working on bug report issues.
■ Jan_Blomqvist_Kinander will move the Fezile server to the concrete bunker creating a
LAN behind Fezile to get automated tests on real hardware.
■ Johannes Anderwald will work in HID (Human Interface Devices for USB) support during
the summer, a hard task as it is completly undocumented.
■ Maciej_Bialas is working on mediawiki integration for the new revamped site.
■ Matthias_Kupfer has been bugfixing and commiting some patches.
■ Pierre_Schweitzer has no time nor willingness right now. Once time will be
back,he'll invest it in his summer student.Once willingness will be back, he'll
keep on his current ReactOS work and help with the ReactOS infrastructure
■ Olaf_Siejka is waiting for Aleksey to finish the LDR code so he can team up with him to
solve the remaining issues of sysreg4. After finishing the utf-8 resource conversion, he
will get more involved in testing. He will also help with the hardware testbot from the
buildbot side.
■ Sylvain_Petreolle is working on French translations.
■ Timo_Kreuzer is working on MSVC builds fixing several bugs that prevent ReactOS to
reach the desktop.
■ Victor_Martinez has finished his exams recently and now he’s preparing a forum team to
test the revision before the LDR rewrite and the one after it, this way it'll be
easier to find regressions. Also he will help with the revamp webpage.
○ Point 6: Suggestions
---------------------------
■ Jan_Blomqvist_Kinander suggested to create a ReactOS annual bootcamp with devs,
testers and fanatics plus having a look at SAMBA 4 - ROS port
○ Meeting closed at 22:08 UTC by Colin Finck on behalf of Aleksey Bragin.
○ Minutes written by Víctor Martínez.
○ Reviewed by Amine_Khaldi, and Gabriel_Ilardi