Re: [ros-dev] Empty fields of DeviceNode leading to Death

[Filip Navara]

art yerkes wrote:

>  Is there a reference for which registry keys fill (or
> are supposed to fill)
> which members of DeviceNode?  I ask because I wind up finding all of the
> combinations that lead to zeros and have a tough time figuring out which
> registry values are needed to make them not be zero.
>   
>  
- Only ServiceName is read from the registry and stored in the device node.
- The rest is queried from the PDO created by bus driver (and possibly 
filtered by higher level drivers).
- Some values are stored in registry and retrieved using 
IoGetDeviceProperty.

>  We have a lot of unchecked string functions on the
> DeviceNode fields in
> io/pnpmgr.c, by the way.  I think i've stumbled on four such places so
> far, but I suspect that the whole thing should be hardened together.
>   
>  
Can you be more specific about this? Which strings? Which places?

>  In any case it would be nice if someone could post a
> cheat sheet about
> how to create a new device entry the right way,
>  
It pretty much depends on the type of driver and the driver itself...

>  or write the code that
> fills the DeviceNode in a more obvious way, so that it's easy to find
> and see what fills what.
>  
That's really hard. The current code (starting from 
IopInvalidateDeviceRelations) does several passes over the device tree 
and in each pass fills one part of the DEVICE_NODE. I can't really think 
about some clearer way...

Regards,
Filip