Re: [ros-dev] Using git for all ros source as main revision control

[Alexey Komarov]

I'm using git on XP with TortoiseGit ( 
http://code.google.com/p/tortoisegit/ ) and it's work perfectly. I am 
not vote to use DVCS. I very like idea to using SHA-1 hash for identify 
objects (and revisions). I never use Mercurial, but as i know, it also 
using SHA-1 hash.. Perhaps Mercurial or Bazaar is better, then Git for 
ros, but i'm sure that, git is much better for ros, than svn.

King InuYasha wrote:
>   No BLOODY WAY! Git is a pain to use and the tortoise
> extensions have 
>  some serious performance problems when dealing with large 
>  repositories. If we are going to DVCS, go to Mercurial, at least that 
>  one supports Windows and offers all the same advantages of Git, albeit 
>  not at as high of a performance gain as Git because of it being cross 
>  platform and not using POSIX features to heavily optimize it. It's 
>  still good. In fact, I use Mercurial to check out the latest revisions 
>  of ReactOS because SVN has a horrible problem of locking up my 
>  computer for hours on end before actually downloading the repository.
>
>  Also, even though Git has come a long way, its not quite as easy to 
>  use as Mercurial. And if anyone suggest Bazaar, I have one thing to 
>  say: Slow Interpreted Performance. It could be better, but it isn't.
>
>  If ReactOS's target was UNIX systems, then Git would be okay. But this 
>  is a Windows reimplementation. That implies Windows users.