Re: 12739: Add sample build script.

[Martin Fuchs]

Hi,

if you want to replace the Makefile build system, please consider using bjam:
http://boost.org/tools/build/jam_src/

It has the following advantages:

- automatic dependency checking

- resolves dependencies in memory without invoking
  multiple levels of Makefiles

- supports nearly every compiler toolset out there, see:
  http://boost.org/more/getting_started.html#Tools


On 02.01.2005 23:17:03 chorns(a)svn.reactos.com wrote:
>   Add sample build script. 

>   Added files:
>  branches/xmlbuildsystem/reactos/ReactOS.xml

[Royce Mitchell III]

Martin Fuchs wrote:

>  Hi,
>
> if you want to replace the Makefile build system, please consider using bjam:
> http://boost.org/tools/build/jam_src/
>
> It has the following advantages:
>
> - automatic dependency checking
>
> - resolves dependencies in memory without invoking
>   multiple levels of Makefiles
>
> - supports nearly every compiler toolset out there, see:
>   http://boost.org/more/getting_started.html#Tools
>   
>  
If you want, you're welcome to setup a vote to decide what we want to 
transition to, but at the moment almost nobody wants to introduce new 
external dependencies.

[Martin Fuchs]

Hello Royce,

>   If you want, you're welcome to setup a vote to
> decide what we want to 
>  transition to, but at the moment almost nobody wants to introduce new 
>  external dependencies. 
I don't understand your rigid resistance about any "external dependencies".
(B)jam.exe is just one single executable you would have to install. It replaces
make.exe. The only difference is, that make is included in MinGW.
It would also be possible to include the source and build it as just one
more tool in the startup phase of the build process. It's freeware.

What is more important than a question about "more dependencies or not"
is, that the build system had to be redesigned when switching from
Makefiles to Jamfiles. Perhaps it may be possible to tweak the
currently emerging Makefiel generator to also generate Jamfiles?

Regards,

    Martin

[David Kredba]

The same apply to bison too.

Regards, David

>   I don't understand your rigid resistance about any
> "external dependencies".
>  (B)jam.exe is just one single executable you would have to install. It replaces
>  make.exe. The only difference is, that make is included in MinGW.
>  It would also be possible to include the source and build it as just one
>  more tool in the startup phase of the build process. It's freeware.
>  
>  What is more important than a question about "more dependencies or not"
>  is, that the build system had to be redesigned when switching from
>  Makefiles to Jamfiles. Perhaps it may be possible to tweak the
>  currently emerging Makefiel generator to also generate Jamfiles?
>  
>  Regards,
>  
>      Martin
>  
>  _______________________________________________
>  Ros-dev mailing list
>  Ros-dev(a)reactos.com
>  http://reactos.com:8080/mailman/listinfo/ros-dev
>