lwIP testing request

[Cameron Gutman]

LwIP is in the final stage of testing, pending one bug fix before all known bugs are
fixed. I would greatly appreciate everyone to try it and reply to this email with the
results of your tests. I've already tried many apps including telnetd, chargen, and
abyss web server, samba tng, and Opera 9.6. During my testing, the lwIP implementation
performed flawlessly. It handled several chargen sessions while serving web pages and
servicing open telnet sessions plus being probed by nmap. The only thing that finally
killed the server was a pool leak that caused a win32k assert failure. I also ran a
BitTorrent download and it peaked at 2.3 MB/s down. Web browsing is an absolute pleasure
on lwIP. It really feels like I'm browsing on the host system directly. There are no
more stutters like oskit had. I'd encourage everyone to try it. It's surprising
how well it works especially since I thought oskit was fairly good. My testing on lwIP has
been perfect and I hope everyone else has a similar experience. Please only report bugs
that don't also happen with oskit. Happy testing!

LwIP ISO Link: http://www.mediafire.com/?d6j4qwz8vgabj9i

Thanks in advance,
Cameron

[WaxDragon]

I'll give it a spin.
On Aug 6, 2011 2:58 PM, "Cameron Gutman" <cameron.gutman(a)reactos.org>
wrote:
>   LwIP is in the final stage of testing, pending one bug
> fix before all 
known bugs are fixed. I would greatly appreciate everyone to try it
and
reply to this email with the results of your tests. I've already tried many
apps including telnetd, chargen, and abyss web server, samba tng, and Opera
9.6. During my testing, the lwIP implementation performed flawlessly. It
handled several chargen sessions while serving web pages and servicing open
telnet sessions plus being probed by nmap. The only thing that finally
killed the server was a pool leak that caused a win32k assert failure. I
also ran a BitTorrent download and it peaked at 2.3 MB/s down. Web browsing
is an absolute pleasure on lwIP. It really feels like I'm browsing on the
host system directly. There are no more stutters like oskit had. I'd
encourage everyone to try it. It's surprising how well it works especially
since I thought oskit was fairly good. My testing on lwIP has been perfect
and I hope everyone else has a similar experience. Please only report bugs
that don't also happen with oskit. Happy testing!
>  
>  LwIP ISO Link: http://www.mediafire.com/?d6j4qwz8vgabj9i
>
>  Thanks in advance,
>  Cameron
>  _______________________________________________
>  Ros-dev mailing list
>  Ros-dev(a)reactos.org
>  http://www.reactos.org/mailman/listinfo/ros-dev

[Cameron Gutman]

The final known bug with lwIP has been fixed and now ws2_32:sock no longer 
drops data. Unless another bug is discovered, this is the golden master 
which will be merged into trunk.

Here an updated ISO to test: http://www.mediafire.com/?84kz5tnu2fjb1pt

Thanks,
Cameron

-----Original Message----- 
From: Cameron Gutman
Sent: Saturday, August 06, 2011 2:57 PM
To: ros-dev(a)reactos.org
Subject: [ros-dev] lwIP testing request

LwIP is in the final stage of testing, pending one bug fix before all known 
bugs are fixed. I would greatly appreciate everyone to try it and reply to 
this email with the results of your tests. I've already tried many apps 
including telnetd, chargen, and abyss web server, samba tng, and Opera 9.6. 
During my testing, the lwIP implementation performed flawlessly. It handled 
several chargen sessions while serving web pages and servicing open telnet 
sessions plus being probed by nmap. The only thing that finally killed the 
server was a pool leak that caused a win32k assert failure. I also ran a 
BitTorrent download and it peaked at 2.3 MB/s down. Web browsing is an 
absolute pleasure on lwIP. It really feels like I'm browsing on the host 
system directly. There are no more stutters like oskit had. I'd encourage 
everyone to try it. It's surprising how well it works especially since I 
thought oskit was fairly good. My testing on lwIP has been perfect and I 
hope everyone else has a similar experience. Please only report bugs that 
don't also happen with oskit. Happy testing!

LwIP ISO Link: http://www.mediafire.com/?d6j4qwz8vgabj9i

Thanks in advance,
Cameron
_______________________________________________
Ros-dev mailing list
Ros-dev(a)reactos.org
http://www.reactos.org/mailman/listinfo/ros-dev

[Amine Khaldi]

Hi,

Considering the fact that lwip is on part with oskittcp, and that it's 
part of a GSoC project (which isn't over yet), it would be of great help 
to merge lwip to trunk. This will ensure broader testing (you'll soon 
realize that no one will test your iso, Cameron) and reveal issues while 
the project is still not over.

So I suggest we merge lwip to trunk ASAP, we have Cameron and Claudiu to 
fix any issues that arise, and the situation can't, in any way, be worse 
than the actual oskit based networking experience.

Regards,
Amine.

[Cameron Gutman]

I agree. If no one has objections, I'm going to merge.


Cameron

-----Original Message----- 
From: Amine Khaldi 
Sent: Sunday, August 07, 2011 12:26 PM 
To: ReactOS Development List 
Subject: Re: [ros-dev] lwIP testing request 

Hi,

Considering the fact that lwip is on part with oskittcp, and that it's 
part of a GSoC project (which isn't over yet), it would be of great help 
to merge lwip to trunk. This will ensure broader testing (you'll soon 
realize that no one will test your iso, Cameron) and reveal issues while 
the project is still not over.

So I suggest we merge lwip to trunk ASAP, we have Cameron and Claudiu to 
fix any issues that arise, and the situation can't, in any way, be worse 
than the actual oskit based networking experience.

Regards,
Amine.

_______________________________________________
Ros-dev mailing list
Ros-dev(a)reactos.org
http://www.reactos.org/mailman/listinfo/ros-dev

[Gregor Schneider]

Hi altogether,

I just tried second ISO and got to say that the download performance using
lwip is marvellous. Great work Claudiu, Art & Cameron!
One minor quirk was the corrupted Firefox 5 download, but that might have
been due to other components and not lwip itself.

Apart from downloads, basically nothing in ReactOS works which is quite
awkward.
These are some of the problems I encountered:
rapps.exe -> internet & network -> firefox 5 -> file corrupt after download
rapps.exe -> internet & network -> firefox 3.0 -> not enough disk space
minimizing rapps.exe gives ~10 riched20 assertions
rapps.exe -> internet & network -> firefox 3.6 -> nothing happens (link
broken?)
rapps.exe -> games -> LGeneral -> SDL.dll cannot be found after
installation, user mode crash

Best regards,
Gregor

Just please merge it back. We can never have too much awesomness in one day.

On Sun, 07 Aug 2011 19:15 +0200, "Gregor Schneider"
<grschneider(a)gmail.com> wrote:
>   Hi altogether,
>  
>  I just tried second ISO and got to say that the download performance
>  using
>  lwip is marvellous. Great work Claudiu, Art & Cameron!
>  One minor quirk was the corrupted Firefox 5 download, but that might have
>  been due to other components and not lwip itself.
>  
>  Apart from downloads, basically nothing in ReactOS works which is quite
>  awkward.
>  These are some of the problems I encountered:
>  rapps.exe -> internet & network -> firefox 5 -> file corrupt after
>  download
>  rapps.exe -> internet & network -> firefox 3.0 -> not enough disk space
>  minimizing rapps.exe gives ~10 riched20 assertions
>  rapps.exe -> internet & network -> firefox 3.6 -> nothing happens (link
>  broken?)
>  rapps.exe -> games -> LGeneral -> SDL.dll cannot be found after
>  installation, user mode crash
>  
>  Best regards,
>  Gregor
>  
>  _______________________________________________
>  Ros-dev mailing list
>  Ros-dev(a)reactos.org
>  http://www.reactos.org/mailman/listinfo/ros-dev 
With best regards
Caemyr

[Cameron Gutman]

I've performed some winetest comparisons:

        Test                                           lwIP 
OSKit
winhttp:notification              231 executed - 0 failures 
231 executed - 0 failures
winhttp:wininet                    451 executed - 6 failures 
451 executed - 6 failures
wininet:http                        1372 executed - 27 failures 
1206 executed - 45 failures
wininet:ftp                            211 executed - 7 failures 
211 executed - 7 failures
ws2_32:sock                     66780 executed - 69 failures 
CRASHED (User-mode)
ws2_32:ioctlsocket                 21 executed - 0 failures 
21 executed - 0 failures
ws2_32:recv                            16 executed - 0 failures 
16 executed - 0 failures

Based on these tests, lwIP looks great and ready for merge.

Thanks,
Cameron

-----Original Message----- 
From: Cameron Gutman
Sent: Saturday, August 06, 2011 7:26 PM
To: ReactOS Development List
Subject: Re: [ros-dev] lwIP testing request

The final known bug with lwIP has been fixed and now ws2_32:sock no longer
drops data. Unless another bug is discovered, this is the golden master
which will be merged into trunk.

Here an updated ISO to test: http://www.mediafire.com/?84kz5tnu2fjb1pt

Thanks,
Cameron

-----Original Message----- 
From: Cameron Gutman
Sent: Saturday, August 06, 2011 2:57 PM
To: ros-dev(a)reactos.org
Subject: [ros-dev] lwIP testing request

LwIP is in the final stage of testing, pending one bug fix before all known
bugs are fixed. I would greatly appreciate everyone to try it and reply to
this email with the results of your tests. I've already tried many apps
including telnetd, chargen, and abyss web server, samba tng, and Opera 9.6.
During my testing, the lwIP implementation performed flawlessly. It handled
several chargen sessions while serving web pages and servicing open telnet
sessions plus being probed by nmap. The only thing that finally killed the
server was a pool leak that caused a win32k assert failure. I also ran a
BitTorrent download and it peaked at 2.3 MB/s down. Web browsing is an
absolute pleasure on lwIP. It really feels like I'm browsing on the host
system directly. There are no more stutters like oskit had. I'd encourage
everyone to try it. It's surprising how well it works especially since I
thought oskit was fairly good. My testing on lwIP has been perfect and I
hope everyone else has a similar experience. Please only report bugs that
don't also happen with oskit. Happy testing!

LwIP ISO Link: http://www.mediafire.com/?d6j4qwz8vgabj9i

Thanks in advance,
Cameron
_______________________________________________
Ros-dev mailing list
Ros-dev(a)reactos.org
http://www.reactos.org/mailman/listinfo/ros-dev


_______________________________________________
Ros-dev mailing list
Ros-dev(a)reactos.org
http://www.reactos.org/mailman/listinfo/ros-dev

[Oleg Baikalow]

I feel sorry for my absence when I promised you all to work on the
networking, but suddenly I had a lot of work to finish before I get free
time again. I want to say you did a very great work! I tested trunk ISO a
couple of days ago, trying simple like downloading files using FireFox,
browsing web and it was so good experience.

I will ask Aleksey to update my branch, and I will pick up a different task
for ReactOS this time. Your OS really becomes usable, good work!

// Oleg

2011/8/6 Cameron Gutman <cameron.gutman(a)reactos.org>

>   LwIP is in the final stage of testing, pending one bug
> fix before all known
>  bugs are fixed. I would greatly appreciate everyone to try it and reply to
>  this email with the results of your tests. I've already tried many apps
>  including telnetd, chargen, and abyss web server, samba tng, and Opera 9.6.
>  During my testing, the lwIP implementation performed flawlessly. It handled
>  several chargen sessions while serving web pages and servicing open telnet
>  sessions plus being probed by nmap. The only thing that finally killed the
>  server was a pool leak that caused a win32k assert failure. I also ran a
>  BitTorrent download and it peaked at 2.3 MB/s down. Web browsing is an
>  absolute pleasure on lwIP. It really feels like I'm browsing on the host
>  system directly. There are no more stutters like oskit had. I'd encourage
>  everyone to try it. It's surprising how well it works especially since I
>  thought oskit was fairly good. My testing on lwIP has been perfect and I
>  hope everyone else has a similar experience. Please only report bugs that
>  don't also happen with oskit. Happy testing!
>
>  LwIP ISO Link: http://www.mediafire.com/?d6j4qwz8vgabj9i
>
>  Thanks in advance,
>  Cameron
>  _______________________________________________
>  Ros-dev mailing list
>  Ros-dev(a)reactos.org
>  http://www.reactos.org/mailman/listinfo/ros-dev
>

[Bernd Blaauw]

Op 18-8-2011 10:35, Oleg Baikalow schreef:
>   I will ask Aleksey to update my branch, and I will
> pick up a different
>  task for ReactOS this time. Your OS really becomes usable, good work! 
If I remember correctly lwIP was recently either merged into trunk, or 
into Cmake version of ReactOS. I'd agree ReactOS is becoming quite 
usable, and am looking forward to 0.4.0 (be it with or without sound and 
USB) hopefully sometime this year.
The merger/reactivation of the ACPI HAL makes it feel at least like an 
ATX machine again :)