RE: [ros-diffs] [mflyer] 21918: Sorry Ged, but that's not the Rea ctOS logo.

[mf]

>   The ReactOS logo is an ugly design. 
Until you
manage to get that wonky off-balance thing you prefer to be
accepted as the official logo, whether it is ugly or not is not
relevant. There is a procedure for changing established things. Your
method of just going ahead and changing things without asking is not
only rude but wrong. If you want to change things, you will have to go
through me first. If you have a problem with me, you have a problem
with changing things. So I suggest you consider your options.

>   Also, it's far too complex to be used as a start
> button image and looks out 
of place.
It's a bloody orb with wisps (rings) around it. Complex my eye.

>   The official Windows logo isn't used on the start
> button. A neater version 
is used in the same way.

A "neater version". You mean the shadow? I have employed a similar way
to make the icon clear at 16x16:

http://img55.imageshack.us/img55/4972/startthingie3yn.png

As you can see, both with Windows and with ReactOS, it's practically
the same thing. I'm beginning to get the idea you are making arguments
up for the sake of having arguments in your offence.

>   This logo is the original ReactOS start menu logo and
> should be kept IMO. 
It's as much a placeholder as the "original"
Everaldo icons were.

mf

[Magnus Olsen]

Hi
The new logo se does not look like reactos any longer
it is to dark and pixel, the balas and constrast in the new
logo is bad, it does not match at all, and it look not prof
have made it. more like a childer. So please revert
the new logo and keep, the old one.

If u look in ros it does not match the constrast or
any think. A logo should not be pixel or constat
does not match. That is exacly in the new logo
u have done MF.

I know it is alot people reactos user and
devloper dislike the new logo.
if u do not revert it, (restore to the old one)
I will do it this weekend.

Magnus Olsen (GreatLord)
ReactOS Devloper




----- Original Message ----- 
From: "mf" <mf(a)mufunyo.net>
To: <ros-general(a)reactos.org>
Sent: Thursday, May 18, 2006 11:53 PM
Subject: [ros-general] RE: [ros-diffs] [mflyer] 21918: Sorry Ged,but that's
not the Rea ctOS logo.


> >   The ReactOS
> > logo is an ugly design. 
>  Until you manage to get that wonky off-balance thing you
> prefer to be
>  accepted as the official logo, whether it is ugly or not is not
>  relevant. There is a procedure for changing established things. Your
>  method of just going ahead and changing things without asking is not
>  only rude but wrong. If you want to change things, you will have to go
>  through me first. If you have a problem with me, you have a problem
>  with changing things. So I suggest you consider your options.
>
>  > Also, it's far too complex to be used as a start button image and looks
out
>   of place.
>  It's a bloody orb with wisps (rings) around it. Complex my eye.
>
>  > The official Windows logo isn't used on the start button. A neater
version
>   is used in the same way.
>
>  A "neater version". You mean the shadow? I have employed a similar way
>  to make the icon clear at 16x16:
>
>  http://img55.imageshack.us/img55/4972/startthingie3yn.png
>
>  As you can see, both with Windows and with ReactOS, it's practically
>  the same thing. I'm beginning to get the idea you are making arguments
>  up for the sake of having arguments in your offence.
>
>  > This logo is the original ReactOS start menu logo and should be kept 
IMO.
>   It's as much a placeholder as the
> "original" Everaldo icons were.
>
>  mf
>
>  _______________________________________________
>  Ros-general mailing list
>  Ros-general(a)reactos.org
>  http://www.reactos.org/mailman/listinfo/ros-general

[Alex Ionescu]

mf and Ged wrote:
>   A Flame war 
Damn, what is this? UI Flame wars and arguments on graphics!??
I better go back to coding so we can have REAL fights about kernel
syncronization objects!

Best regards,
Alex Ionescu