Website Design Voting

[Freeworld]

Hello folks!

Things are going very well with the new site and it is time that the
community/developers choose a design for our now homepage. The choices:
(Thanks to Klemens Friedl for carrying the suggestions together and for
all his other work.)

1) Jason Filby:
   http://reactos.com/newsite/reactos_index.html
http://reactos.com/newsite/reactos_index.html

2) Klemens Friedl:
   http://frik85.fr.funpic.de/reactos/ http://frik85.fr.funpic.de/reactos/

3) Mikko Tikkanen (created the layaut, only a pic)
   http://devnet.dnsalias.net/guidesign/web_mockup.jpg
http://devnet.dnsalias.net/guidesign/web_mockup.jpg (Mikko Tikkanen
   design)
  Brandon Turner (created a html version):
   http://brandonturner.org/ROS/index.html
http://brandonturner.org/ROS/index.html (Brandon Turner work)

4) Mindflyer (based on mikko's design):
   http://www.mufunyo.net/reactos/web/
http://www.mufunyo.net/reactos/web/ (currently not available!)

5) jh:
http://reactos.com:8080/pipermail/ros-web/attachments/20050614/624eb1e9/ros-...
http://reactos.com:8080/pipermail/ros-web/attachments/20050614/624eb1e9/ros-0001.png

6) Gennadiy Dolzhenko:
   http://optim.sorb.com.ua/ros
   http://optim.sorb.com.ua/ros2

Allowed votes are:
1) Jason Filby
2) Klemens Friedl
3) Mikko Tikkanen
4) Mindflyer
5) jh
6) Gennadiy Dolzhenko 1
7) Gennadiy Dolzhenko 1

If the designers name is not right or you want the respective
mailinglist-posting please send me an email.

The voting will last for two weeks.

Greetings
Michael Wirth

[Nathan Samson]

I cant access all websites at the moment but what I have seen now I'll vote on
http://optim.sorb.com.ua/ros/: 6) Gennadiy Dolzhenko 1
BTW: 6) is the same as 7) that number 1 shoulb be 2

2005/8/4, Freeworld [e-mail]:
> Hello folks!
>
> Things are going very well with the new site and it is time that the
> community/developers choose a design for our now homepage. The choices:
> (Thanks to Klemens Friedl for carrying the suggestions together and for
> all his other work.)
> ....

[Freeworld]

Well, sorry for that. Of course it should be like this:

6) Gennadiy Dolzhenko 1
7) Gennadiy Dolzhenko 2

Sad that MFs suggestions can't be accessed. I've uploaded a copy on my
website so the voting is fair. Anyone can change his vote if his
decision changed to MFs design.

Mindflyer's design: http://www.freeworld.net/reactos/index.html

For completeness, here are the designs once again:
1) Jason Filby http://reactos.com/newsite/reactos_index.html
http://reactos.com/newsite/reactos_index.html
2) Klemens Friedl http://frik85.fr.funpic.de/reactos/
http://frik85.fr.funpic.de/reactos/
3) Mikko Tikkanen http://devnet.dnsalias.net/guidesign/web_mockup.jpg
http://devnet.dnsalias.net/guidesign/web_mockup.jpg (Mikko Tikkanen
design)
  Brandon Turner (created a html version):
http://brandonturner.org/ROS/index.html
http://brandonturner.org/ROS/index.html (Brandon Turner work)
4) Mindflyer (based on mikko's design):
http://www.mufunyo.net/reactos/web/
http://www.mufunyo.net/reactos/web/ (currently not available!)
http://www.freeworld.net/reactos/index.html (copy upped by me)
5) jh:
http://reactos.com:8080/pipermail/ros-web/attachments/20050614/624eb1e9/ros-...
http://reactos.com:8080/pipermail/ros-web/attachments/20050614/624eb1e9/ros-0001.png
6) Gennadiy Dolzhenko http://optim.sorb.com.ua/ros
7) Gennadiy Dolzhenko http://optim.sorb.com.ua/ros2
http://optim.sorb.com.ua/ros2

I hope everythings fine now.

Greetings
Michael

Nathan Samson wrote:
> I cant access all websites at the moment but what I have seen now I'll vote on
> http://optim.sorb.com.ua/ros/: 6) Gennadiy Dolzhenko 1
> BTW: 6) is the same as 7) that number 1 shoulb be 2
>
> 2005/8/4, Freeworld [e-mail]:
> > Hello folks!
> >
> > Things are going very well with the new site and it is time that the
> > community/developers choose a design for our now homepage. The choices:
> > (Thanks to Klemens Friedl for carrying the suggestions together and for
> > all his other work.)
> > ....
>
> ros-general mailing list
> [e-mail]
> http://reactos.com/mailman/listinfo/ros-general

[Lucio Diaz]

I only have made a few traductions, so i am more a
user than a developer, but if my vote count for
something this is the best design:

2) Klemens Friedl:
   http://frik85.fr.funpic.de/reactos/ 
http://frik85.fr.funpic.de/reactos/

My vote goes to klemens friedl one.

Best regards

______________________________________________ 
Renovamos el Correo Yahoo! 
Nuevos servicios, más seguridad 
http://correo.yahoo.es

[Gedi]

Freeworld wrote:
> Hello folks!
>
> Things are going very well with the new site and it is time that the
> community/developers choose a design for our now homepage. The choices:
> (Thanks to Klemens Friedl for carrying the suggestions together and for
> all his other work.)

2) Klemens Friedl

It's an inspiring site with a full CMS system designed especially for ROS.
Just wanted to show my support as I know there is an awful lot of work gone into this.

Ged.

[Kevin Hunter]

> Things are going very well with the new site and it is time that the
> community/developers choose a design for our now homepage. The choices:
> (Thanks to Klemens Friedl for carrying the suggestions together and for
> all his other work.)

[snip]
> Allowed votes are:
> Jason Filby
> Klemens Friedl
> Mikko Tikkanen
> Mindflyer
> jh
> Gennadiy Dolzhenko 1
> Gennadiy Dolzhenko 1

I also cannot currently access all of the websites.  From what I am able 
to view, I like different aspects of (1), (2), (3), and (6).  On pure 
looks, I would vote for Mikko's, but I think the CMS behind Klemens' 
site is the clincher.  My vote is for (2), Klemens Friedl's version.

Kevin

[Nathan Samson]

The layout can be implemented into the CMS
If the CMS is written good it must be more or less simple to do
can the source code of the CMS downloaded and freely edited?

2005/8/5, Kevin Hunter [e-mail]:
> > Things are going very well with the new site and it is time that the
> > community/developers choose a design for our now homepage. The choices:
> > (Thanks to Klemens Friedl for carrying the suggestions together and for
> > all his other work.)
>
> [snip]
> > Allowed votes are:
> > Jason Filby
> > Klemens Friedl
> > Mikko Tikkanen
> > Mindflyer
> > jh
> > Gennadiy Dolzhenko 1
> > Gennadiy Dolzhenko 1
>
> I also cannot currently access all of the websites.  From what I am able
> to view, I like different aspects of (1), (2), (3), and (6).  On pure
> looks, I would vote for Mikko's, but I think the CMS behind Klemens'
> site is the clincher.  My vote is for (2), Klemens Friedl's version.
>
> Kevin
> _______________________________________________
> ros-general mailing list
> [e-mail]
> http://reactos.com/mailman/listinfo/ros-general

[Freeworld]

Hmm, whole things gets confusing.

The voting is just over the design Klemens Friedl's CMS system will
anyway be used. Again, you're allowed to change your vote because the
thing wasn't clear...

Greetings
Michael

Kevin Hunter wrote:
> > Things are going very well with the new site and it is time that the
> > community/developers choose a design for our now homepage. The choices:
> > (Thanks to Klemens Friedl for carrying the suggestions together and for
> > all his other work.)
>
> [snip]
> > Allowed votes are:
> > Jason Filby
> > Klemens Friedl
> > Mikko Tikkanen
> > Mindflyer
> > jh
> > Gennadiy Dolzhenko 1
> > Gennadiy Dolzhenko 1
>
> I also cannot currently access all of the websites.  From what I am
> able to view, I like different aspects of (1), (2), (3), and (6).  On
> pure looks, I would vote for Mikko's, but I think the CMS behind
> Klemens' site is the clincher.  My vote is for (2), Klemens Friedl's
> version.
>
> Kevin
> _______________________________________________
> ros-general mailing list
> [e-mail]
> http://reactos.com/mailman/listinfo/ros-general

[Kevin Hunter]

> > I also cannot currently access all of the websites.  From what I am
> > able to view, I like different aspects of (1), (2), (3), and (6).  On
> > pure looks, I would vote for Mikko's, but I think the CMS behind
> > Klemens' site is the clincher.  My vote is for (2), Klemens Friedl's
> > version.
>
> Hmm, whole things gets confusing.
>
> The voting is just over the design Klemens Friedl's CMS system will
> anyway be used. Again, you're allowed to change your vote because the
> thing wasn't clear...

Alright, my vote is for Mikko's design then.

[Saveliy Tretiakov]

I vote for Klemens Friedl design.

vote betwin them are not easy, it is bad not mf webdesign working now, I do not
rember how his look like. Voting in this matter are not easy, everyone have
done good work.

if I start looking at 5) jh  design i like it, nice design no scroll.
nothing say about. I hate website with scroll on main pages. if it as it is to
much info. and it should work with 800x600 for not every one using 1024x768 on
the web. Now to 2) Klemens Friedl design, I like the design more that 5) jh but
it as scrool on main page, that I am against. And I do not rember mf design. so
before I vote, I want see mf design more time. so I can compare these tree
desgin.

Quoting Freeworld [e-mail]:
> Hello folks!
>
> Things are going very well with the new site and it is time that the
> community/developers choose a design for our now homepage. The choices:
> (Thanks to Klemens Friedl for carrying the suggestions together and for
> all his other work.)
> Jason Filby:
> http://reactos.com/newsite/reactos_index.html
>
> http://reactos.com/newsite/reactos_index.html
>
> Klemens Friedl:
> http://frik85.fr.funpic.de/reactos/ http://frik85.fr.funpic.de/reactos/
>
> Mikko Tikkanen (created the layaut, only a pic)
> http://devnet.dnsalias.net/guidesign/web_mockup.jpg
>
> http://devnet.dnsalias.net/guidesign/web_mockup.jpg (Mikko Tikkanen
>    design)
>   Brandon Turner (created a html version):
>    http://brandonturner.org/ROS/index.html
> http://brandonturner.org/ROS/index.html (Brandon Turner work)
> Mindflyer (based on mikko's design):
> http://www.mufunyo.net/reactos/web/
>
> http://www.mufunyo.net/reactos/web/ (currently not available!)
> jh:

http://reactos.com:8080/pipermail/ros-web/attachments/20050614/624eb1e9/ros-...
>

http://reactos.com:8080/pipermail/ros-web/attachments/20050614/624eb1e9/ros-0001.png
> Gennadiy Dolzhenko:
> http://optim.sorb.com.ua/ros
> http://optim.sorb.com.ua/ros2
>
> Allowed votes are:
> Jason Filby
> Klemens Friedl
> Mikko Tikkanen
> Mindflyer
> jh
> Gennadiy Dolzhenko 1
> Gennadiy Dolzhenko 1
>
> If the designers name is not right or you want the respective
> mailinglist-posting please send me an email.
>
> The voting will last for two weeks.
>
> Greetings
> Michael Wirth
> _______________________________________________
> Ros-dev mailing list
> [e-mail]
> http://reactos.com:8080/mailman/listinfo/ros-dev

Hi have seen all tree design and I like all tree in diffet way

5) jh
The top banner with ros logo and it fit in 800x600

mf design
clean and nice design and it also fit in 800x600

2) Klemens Friedl
I like the top banner and the menu system alot. But dislke it does not fit in
800x600 or 1024x768.

If I look what my instik say not my felling it stand betwin jh and mf.
if I look with my feeling and ignore the 800x600 / 1024x768 test. The design I
like most is then Klemens Friedl.

As you can see I can not make make up my mind. But Klemens Friedl. for I like
the design best of all. I hope it can be adpatet to 1024x768 without scrooll on
the main

My vote is
2) Klemens Friedl

Quoting [e-mail]:
> vote betwin them are not easy, it is bad not mf webdesign working now, I do
> not
> rember how his look like. Voting in this matter are not easy, everyone have
> done good work.
>
> if I start looking at 5) jh  design i like it, nice design no scroll.
> nothing say about. I hate website with scroll on main pages. if it as it is
> to
> much info. and it should work with 800x600 for not every one using 1024x768
> on
> the web. Now to 2) Klemens Friedl design, I like the design more that 5) jh
> but
> it as scrool on main page, that I am against. And I do not rember mf design.
> so
> before I vote, I want see mf design more time. so I can compare these tree
> desgin.
>
> Quoting Freeworld [e-mail]:
> > Hello folks!
> >
> > Things are going very well with the new site and it is time that the
> > community/developers choose a design for our now homepage. The choices:
> > (Thanks to Klemens Friedl for carrying the suggestions together and for
> > all his other work.)
> > Jason Filby:
> > http://reactos.com/newsite/reactos_index.html
> >
> > http://reactos.com/newsite/reactos_index.html
> > Klemens Friedl:
> > http://frik85.fr.funpic.de/reactos/
>
> http://frik85.fr.funpic.de/reactos/
> > Mikko Tikkanen (created the layaut, only a pic)
> > http://devnet.dnsalias.net/guidesign/web_mockup.jpg
> >
> > http://devnet.dnsalias.net/guidesign/web_mockup.jpg (Mikko Tikkanen
> >    design)
> >   Brandon Turner (created a html version):
> >    http://brandonturner.org/ROS/index.html
> > http://brandonturner.org/ROS/index.html (Brandon Turner work)
> > Mindflyer (based on mikko's design):
> > http://www.mufunyo.net/reactos/web/
> >
> > http://www.mufunyo.net/reactos/web/ (currently not available!)
> > jh:

http://reactos.com:8080/pipermail/ros-web/attachments/20050614/624eb1e9/ros-...
> >

http://reactos.com:8080/pipermail/ros-web/attachments/20050614/624eb1e9/ros-0001.png
> > Gennadiy Dolzhenko:
> > http://optim.sorb.com.ua/ros
> > http://optim.sorb.com.ua/ros2
> >
> > Allowed votes are:
> > Jason Filby
> > Klemens Friedl
> > Mikko Tikkanen
> > Mindflyer
> > jh
> > Gennadiy Dolzhenko 1
> > Gennadiy Dolzhenko 1
> >
> > If the designers name is not right or you want the respective
> > mailinglist-posting please send me an email.
> >
> > The voting will last for two weeks.
> >
> > Greetings
> > Michael Wirth
> > _______________________________________________
> > Ros-dev mailing list
> > [e-mail]
> > http://reactos.com:8080/mailman/listinfo/ros-dev
>
> Ros-dev mailing list
> [e-mail]
> http://reactos.com:8080/mailman/listinfo/ros-dev

[Klemens Friedl]

> [e-mail] wrote:
>
> ... As you can see I can not make make up my mind. But Klemens Friedl. 
> for I like the design best of all. I hope it can be adpatet to 1024x768 
> without scrooll on the main.

I removed the information about the RosCMS on the frontpage, so the visitors
do not need to scroll (or only a bit on 1024x768). The page is also viewable
on 800x600. Have you also tried some other pages like "media", "download",
etc ? (-> there is no right sidebar)

In addition, it will not be a problem to modify the page layout a bit so the
page will also be viewable in 1024x768 without scrolling. But to do this, i
need the final content for the ReactOS frontpage. Another possibility: I can
resize the top bar (a bit smaller).

Best regars,
Klemens Friedl
-- 
GMX DSL = Maximale Leistung zum minimalen Preis!
2000 MB nur 2,99, Flatrate ab 4,99 Euro/Monat: http://www.gmx.net/de/go/dsl

[Sascha Gehrke]

Can't open half of the suggestions, too, but from what I've seen I vote for

2) Klemens Friedl

[Freeworld]

Strange. At the moment all the suggestions are avalaible. I can access
them. (For mf's design you'll have to use this url:
http://www.freeworld.net/reactos/index.html )

With which suggestions do you have a problem?

Greetings
Michael

Sascha Gehrke wrote:
> Can't open half of the suggestions, too, but from what I've seen I
> vote for
> Klemens Friedl
>
> ros-general mailing list
> [e-mail]
> http://reactos.com/mailman/listinfo/ros-general

[Brandon Mark Turner]

My website hosting(mikko's desgin) is down until i get out of work.  I dont 
know what happened but i can't remote desktop to my normal computer and my 
websites down, so i probably just need to restart my router when i get back.

Brandon

Freeworld writes:
> Strange. At the moment all the suggestions are avalaible. I can access
> them. (For mf's design you'll have to use this url:
> http://www.freeworld.net/reactos/index.html )
>
> With which suggestions do you have a problem?
>
> Greetings
> Michael
>
> Sascha Gehrke wrote:
> > Can't open half of the suggestions, too, but from what I've seen I
> > vote for
> > Klemens Friedl
> >
> > ros-general mailing list
> > [e-mail]
> > http://reactos.com/mailman/listinfo/ros-general
>
> ros-general mailing list
> [e-mail]
> http://reactos.com/mailman/listinfo/ros-general

[Nathan Samson]

2005/8/5, Freeworld [e-mail]:
> With which suggestions do you have a problem?

I have only a pbroblem with 
http://devnet.dnsalias.net/guidesign/web_mockup.jpg

[Ivan Vodopiviz]

Hi, my vote goes to

6) Gennadiy Dolzhenko 1
http://optim.sorb.com.ua/ros/

Anyway, all of them look great! Nice work people! :-)

On 8/5/05, Nathan Samson [e-mail] wrote:
> 2005/8/5, Freeworld [e-mail]:
> > With which suggestions do you have a problem?
>
> I have only a pbroblem with
> http://devnet.dnsalias.net/guidesign/web_mockup.jpg
>
> ros-general mailing list
> [e-mail]
> http://reactos.com/mailman/listinfo/ros-general
-- 
BlueSteel | | Merkoth

[Henrik Kirk]

I vote for > 5) jh.

But nice design everyone
-- 

Henrik Bitsch Kirk
86298725 / 60688725
[e-mail]
http://www.busywait.org

Webmaster: www.1900mtb.dk

Reality is bad enough, why should I tell the truth?
    	-- Patrick Sky

[Emanuele Aliberti]

Freeworld wrote:
> Allowed votes are:
> Jason Filby
> Klemens Friedl
> Mikko Tikkanen
> Mindflyer
> jh
> Gennadiy Dolzhenko 1
> Gennadiy Dolzhenko 1

I vote for 2).
-- 
:Emanuele Aliberti